Beloved (2011)

Promotional still from the film

Christophe Honoré is by far my favorite director. I first came across his films in high school when I rented his film Dans Paris from Blockbuster. Since that chance encounter with him, I have not been able to get enough. I've seen pretty much his entire filmography, and that includes films produced by him, presented by him, written by him, and of course those directed by him. Until seeing Beloved, however, I had never seen one of his films in theaters. So when I saw that the Criterion Cinema in downtown New Haven was showing it, I knew it was a chance I couldn't pass up.

Honoré has a very distinct style. It is often celebrated by critics, but also condemned. After the release of his 2004 Ma Mère and 2006 Dans Paris, Honoré was praised as the grandchild of the New Wave, which is one of the most influential film movements of the recent age. In recent years, however, he has been criticized as becoming too sentimental. With this last sentiment, I would have to disagree. 

Beloved is Honoré's second musical. It follows the lives of two women over the course of their lives, documenting their loves and their losses and everything in between. The two women are mother and daughter. The mother, played by legendary Catherine Deneuve, has long standing affair with the love of her life, father of her child, and once husband, even though she divorced him and married again. The daughter falls in love with a gay man, all the while ignoring the one man who loves her for who she is. 

The film is documented in segments of decades. This allows the exploration of various facets of the women's lives and how time has or hasn't changed them. There is also a parallel created between mother and daughter. Decisions that have been made by the mother are decisions that the daughter tries desperately to replicate, but the gravity of her situation of being in love with a gay man forever blocked her from any type of true happiness or contentedness that her mother might have found. This can show the affects of an upbringing and the environment that a child grows up in, not to mention the changing of the times. While the mother remains married to her current husband, having an affair on the side, she finds a way to balance her lives and have some semblance of happiness. The mother is from a time of the past, where a sort of restrained nature is applauded over acting out. This is a time that the daughter can't replicate. Even with the openness of relationships and sexuality in the modern age, the daughter cannot hold together the two relationships she has, the one with the gay man and the one with the man who truly loves her.

As a whole, the film was very well put together. It was very distinctly Honoré, which is what I love to see. There is a lack of explanation in his films, but rather a focus on shots to do the explaining lost in the dialogue. A lot of what you feel when watching Beloved comes from from exactly that, watching. There is much more to pick up from the photography than from the writing. The only thing I would have to put in the negatives for this film was it's soundtrack. The fact that the film was a musical greatly took away from its impact. Aside from one or two of the songs, most of the music felt forced and out of place. It felt like I was watching a musical rather than a film, which Honoré has avoided in the past. Over all I give this film a B-.